QA：如果1000万移民被驱逐出境，美国经济会发生什么？
What will happen to the US economy if ten million immigrants are deported?
译文简介
崩溃，暴跌，坠落。
正文翻译
What will happen to the US economy if ten million immigrants are deported?
如果1000万移民被驱逐出境，美国经济会发生什么？
评论翻译
很赞 ( 2 )
收藏
It would cost a ton of taxpayer money just to find and deport everyone. Especially since it will have to go through the courts. A ton of them detained and will have to be fed and housed. No longer working no longer paying taxes or buying in our economy. With labor shortages expect slow downs and higher prices.
仅仅是找到所有人，并将其驱逐出境，就需要花费纳税人大量的钱。尤其是这件事情还需要通过法庭才可以实施。他们中的许多人将被拘留，所以政府不得不给他们提供食物和住所。他们将不再工作、不再纳税、不再在我们的经济中购买商品。由于劳动力短缺，预计经济会放缓，商品价格会上涨。
I think there are 10 million better choices to deport. Start with all the January 6 traitors, deport them to Afghanistan in a rowboat without oars.
我认为有1000万个更好的选择可以驱逐出境。从1月6日所有的暴徒开始吧，用没有桨的划艇将他们驱逐到阿富汗。
A lot of employers will have to start paying living wages.
许多雇主将不得不开始支付最低生活工资。
These people do the jobs that no one wants, and they often are underpaid. I think companies and farms/ranches that use this labor pool are going to be badly impacted, but maybe they should be. Take a look at Florida. There are not enough people to clean hotel rooms or harvest crops now that DeSantis draconian laws are being implemented. I wonder how that is going over right now.
这些人做的工作是没人愿意做的，而且他们的工资往往很低。我认为使用这一劳动力库的公司和农场/牧场将受到严重影响，但也许他们应该受到严重影响。看看佛罗里达州。现在罗恩·德桑蒂斯严厉的法律正在实施，没有足够的人来打扫酒店房间或收割作物。我想知道现在情况如何。
Worse case It could grind to a halt. but if not it will still not be good for the US economy, can you say recession, perhaps more extensive than 2008–10 actually? That is exactly why it will never happen. The business interests who have many of Washington’s “leaders” in their pack pockets won’t allow it!
更糟糕的情况是，美国可能会陷入停顿。但如果不是这样，这对美国经济仍然没有好处，你甚至可以说是衰退，实际上可能比2008-2010年的情况更广泛？这正是驱逐移民永远不会发生的原因。这个里面有很多华盛顿“领导人”的商业利益，他们不会允许这样做！
Not much. Finding and deporting 10 million illegals will take years. Those vacancies will be filled by LEGAL migrants who have applied, been vetted, and issued green card status as guest workers.
不怎么样。发现和驱逐1000万非法移民需要数年时间。这些空缺将由合法移民填补。他们已经申请、通过了审查，并作为外来工人获得了绿卡。
Crash, plummet, fall. “Americans are leaving Middle America and the only people who are moving in are immigrants. Metro areas here grew mostly because of the immigrant population. This adds up to 50 percent of the total growth in some areas. New waves of immigrants are making these areas demographically younger.”
They are also most of the agricultural workers. Wait until food prices skyrocket!
崩溃，暴跌，坠落。
“美国人正在离开美国中部，唯一搬进来的人是移民。这里的大都市地区之所以增长，主要是因为移民人口。移民在一些地区占总增长的50%。新一波移民使这些地区在人口统计学上更年轻。”
大多数的农业工人也是他们。等着吧，食品价格会飞涨！
Most food production would stop.
Many employers would close or move to other countries. Their American employees would lose their jobs.
Because of the drop in food production, more food would need to be imported.
1、大多数粮食生产将停止。
2、许多雇主会关闭或迁往其他国家。他们的美国雇员将失去工作。
3、由于粮食产量下降，需要进口更多的粮食。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Less taxpayer funds paying for their upkeep. More legal employment where taxes are collected. Less risk of terrorism. Less organized criminals free to walk the streets. Basically a safer and richer USA
用于维护的纳税人资金会减少。更多的合法就业，这会产生税收。恐怖主义风险降低。有组织的犯罪将减少，人们可以自由地走在街上。基本上会是一个更安全、更富裕的美国。
When Trump does this the economy will boom with more jobs & opportunities
当特朗普做到这一点时，经济将蓬勃发展，带来更多的就业和机会。
the econ is in shambles thanks to bidens inflation. the illegals are also pushing cities and states into debt caring for them
由于拜登的通货膨胀，经济陷入混乱。非法移民还迫使城市和州为照顾他们而负债。
Nothing bad, I can assure you. However, ten million isn't enough. Get them all out.
我可以向你保证，这不会有什么不好的。然而，1000万是不够的。把他们都弄出去。
I mean, we already had a taste of that when Florida implemented its more strict immigration policies.
Florida's immigration law brings significant unintended consequences, critics say
The new sweeping immigration legislation, signed into law by Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis in May of 2022, prohibits anyone from transporting illegal immigrants into the state.
我的意思是，当佛罗里达州实施更严格的移民政策时，我们已经尝到了这种滋味。
批评人士称，佛罗里达州的移民法带来了重大的意外后果。
佛罗里达州州长罗恩·德桑蒂斯于2022年5月签署成为法律的新的全面的移民立法：禁止任何人将非法移民运送到该州。
我们看到食物在地里腐烂，因为没有人去摘。我记得，我读到一位农民向任何愿意采摘土豆的人开放了他们的土豆农场，他们可以保留他们采摘的东西。农民不希望土豆在地里腐烂。然而，没有人来。我看到了很多空荡荡的建筑工地和半成品房屋的视频。如果我们驱逐所有非法移民和季节性劳工，美国经济将在一夜之间崩溃。
Be careful what you wish for, Robert. It might not end the way you like.
这还只是非法移民。如果你想驱逐所有移民……嗯，这大约占总人口的97%。2021年，美国有970万人被认定为美洲印第安人或阿拉斯加原住民，占总人口的2.9%。
我们谈论的是驱逐3亿多人。
即使我们把每一个声称自己家族中有切罗基公主血统的白人都算作“部分土著人”，我们最终仍会驱逐大约一半的人，其中还包括了第一次世界大战和第二次世界大战期间来自欧洲的所有人。
提问者Robert Van Dusen也很有可能也会被驱逐出境，因为Van Dusen（或Van Dursen、Ven Deusen等）是一个独特的荷兰姓氏。
小心许愿，Robert 。它可能会以你不喜欢的方式结束。
You know he doesn’t mean “immigrants” he means non-white people. Non Christian people. Deport all those people Trump doesn’t like, Including all Democrats.
你知道的，他不是指“移民”，他指的是非白人、非基督徒。驱逐所有特朗普不喜欢的人，包括所有民主党人。
In a way, the U.S. economy collapsing would be the ultimate form of karma for Red States. Hell, it’d be karma for most of America that fails to realize undocumented immigrants are what keep us the superpower that we are (for now, at least).
在某种程度上来说，红州因果报应的最终形式，将是美国经济的崩溃。见鬼，对大多数美国人来说，如果没有意识到无证移民是我们保持超级大国地位的原因（至少目前如此），那将是因果报应。
Angry Americans will enslave Republicans to take over the unfilled jobs.
愤怒的美国人将奴役共和党人来接管空缺的工作。
Not true Steve as we don’t enslave people as a nation anymore, I do think our country should be run like others. Strict border entry’s with a passport stating why you are here, who you are staying with, the reason for visiting the US (business or pleasure) how long are you staying! Do you have anything to declare for tax reasons, a search and now it’s time to leave.
We have many real Americans that don’t work, stop giving handouts and get our Made in America workforce out there again. We need a New President not a choice of these two again and put Higher sanctions and taxes on China so they can’t ship their shitty mass made products by family’s and their children that have to listen to Wu in fear of the lives. Have a good weekend.
楼上，这不是真的，因为我们再也不会作为一个国家去奴役人民，我确实认为我们的国家应该像其他国家一样治理。
进行严格的边境入境管理，需要人们出示护照，说明他们为什么会出现在这里，和谁住在一起，访问美国的原因（商务还是娱乐），你要呆多久！出于税务原因，你有什么需要申报的吗？搜查一下，然后你就可以离开了。
我们有很多真正的美国人不去工作，停止发放救济金，让我们的美国制造劳动力再次出现。
我们需要一位新总统，而不是再在这两位总统中做出选择，并对中国实施更高的制裁和税收，这样他们就不能通过家人和他们的孩子运送他们的劣质批量生产的产品，因为他们不得不听从 Wu 的话，因为他们担心生命安全。
祝你周末愉快。
We have manufacturing plants opening all over the country. Who will (wo)man them? The unemployment rate is near rock bottom. There are 9 million job openings because we have millionaires all over the place who can and do choose to live their hobbies instead of work.
We are a rich country. People have options for better jobs that leave the entry level jobs unfilled.
我们在全国各地都有制造厂。哪个男人或者女人会去那里工作？失业率接近谷底。有900万个职位空缺，因为我们各地都有富人，他们可以而且确实选择了自己的爱好而不是工作。
我们是一个富裕的国家。人们可以选择更好的工作，让入门级的工作空缺下来。
There are many people that are Not Millionaires, I’m not are you? How about anyone you know. I know a few but they still work and Hire many young people to get them into the workforce! How about you, do you know anyone living the life of Riley doing anything they want when they want????
有很多人不是富人，我就不是，你是吗？你认识的人呢？他们是吗？我知道一些富人，但他们仍然在工作，雇佣了很多年轻人让他们进入职场！
你呢，你知道有谁过着莱利的生活，能想做什么就做什么吗？？？？
There will be more prosperity in the USA. Ten Million less people on various govt. programs that could help homeless and indigent citizens. More than a million jobs available to citizens, including good jobs for our young workers joining the work force for the 1st time. Our citizens can learn how to do anything a illegal immigrant does. The unemployment numbers should decrease in every state saving tax payers millions every month.
Crime should go down. Not all illegal immigrants are criminals but many are. 1% of ten million is 100 Thousand! Fentanyl use and fatalities' should decrease. The cost of controlling and processing the aprox. 100,000 offenders would save the tax payers significant dollars. Not to mention the lives saved.
There’s a lot more areas the USA economy should benefit. Not every job they take is picking fruit, vegetables, or sweat shops.
Illegal immigrants send over 50% (on average) of their income to other countries. This creates a huge imbalance in the flow of income generated and paid by US companies/employers from goods being purchased from overseas with low tariffs, sold in the USA, and that profit returned to other countries.
Government healthcare, education, housing, perishables costs should decrease as well. The USA would probably begin to produce more sustainable products made in the USA vs that imported by non US citizens just because it is natural for all of us to enjoy the foods and goods we grew up with. Its not cruel.
美国将更加繁荣，将减少1000万人的各类政府事务，可以用来帮助无家可归者和贫困的公民。公民可以获得100多万个工作岗位，其中包括为首次加入劳动力队伍的年轻工人提供的好工作。我们的公民可以学习如何做非法移民做的任何事情。每个州的失业人数都会减少，每月为纳税人节省数百万美元。
犯罪会减少。并非所有非法移民都是罪犯，但许多人都是罪犯。千万的1%就是十万！控制和处理犯罪的成本将降低。减少10万名罪犯将为纳税人节省大笔资金。更不用说可以拯救多少生命了。
美国经济会从更多领域受益。并不是所有的工作，都是他们做的那些：采摘水果、蔬菜或血汗工厂等等。
非法移民将其收入的50%（平均）以上汇往其他国家。这造成了美国公司/雇主从海外以低关税购买、在美国销售的商品所产生和支付的收入流的巨大不平衡，而这些利润又回到了其他国家。
政府的医疗、教育、住房和易腐物品成本也会降低。美国可能会开始生产美国制造的比从非美国进口的更可持续的产品，因为我们所有人都很自然地享受与我们一起成长的食物和商品。这并不残忍。
Disaster.
It will not just be 10 million “illegals.” It will be another 10 million US citizens—their kids. Decreasing the population by 10 million workers will not have a positive effect! And sending 10 million US citizens into camps and then to foreign countries. . . well, we actually did the first part of that once before.
And 40 years later, we apologized and paid then $20,000 each.
灾难！
不仅仅是1000万的“非法移民”的问题，还有1000万美国公民——他们的孩子的问题。减少1000万工人不会有积极的效果！将1000万美国公民送往难民营，然后再送往外国……好吧，实际上，我们之前做过第一部分的事情。
40年后，我们道歉，并每人支付了2万美元的补偿。
链接：二战期间，日裔美国人被送往集中营
It will crash from labor shortages
美国将因劳动力短缺而崩溃。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Take a load off the free loads on food stamps an government handouts
减轻了政府发放的免费食品券的负担。
原创翻译：龙腾网 https://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处
Taxpayers won’t have to house, feed and clothe them!
纳税人将不必为他们提供住房、食物和衣服！
The USA would improve, and the economy would be better and people would have jobs
美国会改善，经济会更好，人们会有工作！
The economy would improve because we don’t spend as much money caring for illegals.
经济会有所改善，因为我们不用花那么多钱照顾非法移民。
our bills would go way down
我们的账单会减少很多
Gun Stores and Lock smiths will go out of business
枪支商店和锁匠行业将倒闭。
I will be able to get a job
我会找到一份工作。
Crime and looting would go down.
犯罪和抢劫将会减少。
Exactly ZERO migrants will be deported. Shut the fuck up.
很确定，0个移民会被驱逐出境。闭嘴吧！
Resturaunts will be unaffordable, you will have to mow your own lawn, hospitals will become dirty.
维护费用将无法负担，你将不得不自己修剪草坪，医院将变得肮脏。