Girish Madpuwar
Your confusion comes from the fact that you don't really understand the nature of Indian civilization which has place for everything. That includes animal, insects, birds and all sorts of creatures. This earth is not just for human and not everything else is for human to exploits for own benefit.

你的困惑来自于你并没有真正理解印度文明的本质。在印度文明中,动物,昆虫,鸟类和各种生物都有相应的位置。这个地球不仅仅属于人类的,所有的物质也不是仅供人类利益而开发。

Cow worship is symbolization of care towards nature, love towards other forms of God’s creation. Not only cow.. take snake, it has place in Indian culture, the ugly looking crow too have important place in aspect of human life. Every other animal form has some or other way embedded in the daily walks of life.

对牛的崇拜象征着对自然的关怀,对神创造的其他生命的爱。不仅是牛。拿蛇来说,它在印度文化中也有一席之地,就连相貌丑陋的乌鸦在人类生活中,也有重要的地位。每一种动物都以某种方式融入印度的日常生活中。

Cow has special significance due to milk it give. Cow’s milk is next best food kids are given after mother’s milk. So the connection is deeper. Cow dung is used as fuel, diluted form of it is used for covering walls floor/walls of clay houses. In agricultural society bull was considered asset and cow is source of it. One who owns more bull/cow was considered prosperous. In Mahabharata episode, to provoke Pandavas, Kaurava has stolen cows of king Virat. Staling cow is like stealing wealth. This is just an example. In traditional Indian society, cow is an asset some would want to have.

牛因其所产的奶而具有特殊的意义。牛奶是孩子们仅次于母乳的最好食物。所以牛和人们的联系更深。牛粪可以用作燃料,稀释后的牛粪还可以用于糊墙。在农业社会,公牛被认为是一种财富,母牛是财富的来源。谁拥有更多的牛就会被认为是富裕的。在《摩诃婆罗多》中,为了激怒潘达瓦斯,考拉瓦偷了维拉特国王的牛。偷牛就像偷财富。这只是一个例子。在传统的印度社会,牛是人们想要的财富。

But now cow is being used as just a material for exploration. Either it’s dairy business, or for meat/leather. Some people just look it as means to earn money, or look at it just as food. But how can one take away the deep ingrained emotions in human consciousness just because definition of wealth has change, definition of food has changed for some. After all this connection goes back ages and attachment is ancient.

但现在牛只是被用作生产资料。要么是做奶制品生意,要么是做肉类/皮革生意。有些人只是把它看作是挣钱的手段,或者把它看作是食物。但是,一个人怎么能仅仅因为财富的定义改变了,食物的定义改变了,就把人类意识中根深蒂固的情感拿走呢。毕竟,这种联系可以追溯到很久以前,而这种情感的依恋也是古老的。

As human you are evolved creature and at higher plane to understand this. It’s responsibility of human to look after and respect other forms of creation. If one doesn't understand this then get ready to be born as cow in next life and get ready to be pregnant throughout life so that human can exploit you for milk. And when there is no more milk left, get ready to be killed for meat or leather so that someone can proudly wear you as footwear. If this is not understood, prepare yourself to be born as pig and evolve slowly to human nature through various birth cycles.

作为人类,你们是进化的生物。处于更高的层面去理解这一点,照顾和尊重其他形式的造物,是人类的责任。如果你不明白这一点,那就准备好在下辈子投胎成母牛,并准备好在一生中不断怀孕,以让人类剥削你的牛奶吧。而且当你挤不出奶的时候,就准备好被杀取肉或取皮革,来让人骄傲地穿着你的皮当鞋穿吧。如果你们不明白这一点,就准备好自己投胎成猪,通过各种轮回慢慢投胎成人吧。

Choice is solely yours. As you think so you become. May God give you cows birth next time so that you can test this out yourself

选择权全在你们自己。你们怎么想,你们就会变成什么样。愿神下次让你下辈子投胎成牛,这样你就可以自己体验了。

Kanthaswamy Balasubramaniam
Lets look at this mathematically

让我们从数学角度来看这个问题

No.of cows in India = 206 Million

印度奶牛数量=2.06亿头

Beef Production in 2019 = 3.51 Million Tons

2019年牛肉产量=351万吨
原创翻译:龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处


Weight per cow = 270 Kilograms average

每头牛体重=平均270公斤

No of cows slaughtered a year = 13 million

一年屠宰的奶牛数量=1300万头

Leather exports in 2019 = 1.8 Billion Square Feet

2019年皮革出口量=18亿平方英尺

Average area per cowhide = 50 Squarefeet

每张牛皮的平均面积=50平方英尺

No of cows killed for leather a year = 36 Million

每年因皮革而被杀的奶牛数量=3600万头

Total Cows Killed in a year = 36+13 = 49 Million

一年中死亡的奶牛总数=36+13=4900万头
原创翻译:龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处


Naturally Dead Cattle used in Tanneries and slaughter= 27% (Already dead cattle which died due to natural causes)

用于制革厂和屠宰的自然死亡牛=27%(由于自然原因死亡的已死牛)
原创翻译:龙腾网 http://www.ltaaa.cn 转载请注明出处


So Actual no of Cows killed in a year = 49 million * (100%–27%)= 37 Million roughly

因此,一年中实际死亡的奶牛数量=4900万*(100%-27%)=3700万

So % of cattle killed a year out of the population = 37/204 *100 = 18.13%

因此,每年死亡的牛的百分比=37/204*100=18.13%

No of humans = 1380 Million

人口=13.8亿

No of humans who died in 2019 = 10 Million (At death rate 7.37 per 1000)

2019年死亡人数=1000万

No of humans killed or murdered or who committed suicide or went missing for more than 7 yrs= 77000(As per JNU Crime statistics 2016–2017)

7年以上无人被杀害或谋杀,自杀或失踪人口数=77000

% of Humans killed in 2019= 77000/1380M *100 = 0.006%


2019年死亡人数的百分比=77000/1380万*100=0.006%

Thus a cow has a 3021 times higher chance of being killed in India than a human.So why would anyone want to be a cow?

因此,在印度,一头牛被杀的几率是人的3021倍。所以为什么会有人想做一头母牛呢?

Titu Shyam
Brilliant question.Cows are just being used as sign to spread hatred by some so called humans. It is big business to collect money from Innocent humans.

聪明的问题。奶牛只是被一些所谓的人类用作散布仇恨的标志。从无辜者那里捞钱的大生意。

It is big political debate but we know that on one side are Haters with high BP and sleeping illnesses and otherside are lost intellectuals Eventually everyone suffers

这是一场重大的政治辩论,但我们知道,一边是患有高血压和睡眠疾病的仇恨者,另一边是迷失方向的知识分子。最终每个人都会受苦。

Vivekananda Shetty
It is better to be a Human not only in India but any part of the Universe.

不仅在印度,而且是在宇宙的任何地方,还是当人最好。